Lucky enough to be at this show. Candyman blew everyone away--best song played that night. Awesome trippy guitar jam &Jer belts out vocals

Gorgeous, incredible, up and down, carnival-like bridge jam by Jerry. Picture perfect version--no flaws

April '78 S>F's often mentioned are 4/16 and 4/24 (rightly so) but this one is every bit as good. Superior transition jam--, beautiful, & powerful

Starts out Jazzy, explorative, takes its time, 3 minute intro, then blasts off into the stratosphere with intense Garcia-led jamming

See, I love it when I check the comments and find a version of Scarlet>Fire that's new to my ears and really worthy of upvotes at the same time. Just when you think you've heard 'em all...anyway, this one's a great example of a mellow-tight '79 w/Jer in complete control and a fun transition jam that glides into a great Fire. CM has a full SBD version up too (2nd set only.) Great sound...great version...it's got my vote.

Why does everything played at this show sound so damn good? This is a perfectly sung rendition--and yes, that includes Donna.

^^^ That's a wise approach...I like the idea of the "blind hear test"...although we're all probably pretty well trained enough to know a '91 Scarlet from a '77 the minute it starts playing, whether we have the date in front of us or not. Share away!

^^^ With 5 stars being the best, this is a 4-star version easily. If you're grading on a curve and taking into account the post-90's decline, you could bump it to 4 1/2 and I wouldn't complain. I'm a true believer for this version.

Take maybe a half point off for Jerry's typically croaky '91 vocals, but musically, this is a delight. As noted, Hornsby goes jazz jam all over this version...he's clearly adding color and filling space in ways that are truly rare...this happens in both the meat of Scarlet, the transition to Fire, and while Jerry takes over in Fire as the stand-out, Bruce doesn't miss a beat in providing the perfect back-drop. I'm really hard to please when it comes to nearly anything post-1990 so believe me when I say this version can stand proud with many at or near the top of this list. At the very least it deserves to have more than 20 votes, but sits under-appreciated at 12 as I write this, including the one I just added. Let's up this puppy, please.