Scarlet Begonias -> Fire On The Mountain
May 8, 1977
Barton Hall - Cornell University
My POV, from a discussion w my bro --
i think the bulk of dead purists are the older cats who have an (acknowledged or not) disdain for the Touch of Grey / celeb-era Dead of the 80s. Also, many decry Jerry's vocal losses in the heroin influenced early 80s, but to me thats when things get really interesting ... jams go crazy places with dark hard edged rock and roll... Bob screaming his butt off in Estimateds, Jerry too as in Augusta Dew and that Ventura 84 Loser, as examples.. Brent adds a huge dimension as well -- with Jerry and Phil he is in the top 3 of pure musical talent in the history of the band. '83-85 and '89-90 are my fav eras. 86-88 is good, but generally under-jammed. For me the 70s sound thin and noodly and Donna is more of a turnoff than Vince in the 90s. More technically, i think Jerry was a more evolved player in the 80s -- much more chromatics and less pentatonics, when he bent a string he meant it ..in the 70 he was bending shit all over the place and it frankly sounds lame to me.
EDIT -- at risk of sounding too harsh, i know there's a lot of great stuff in the 70s, particularly the first 3 years (listening to Boston '73 PITB now, wow..) Anyway, to each his own.